Finally went to the store to get some fleece. Walked out with 4 different prints/colors. In addition to hats (and mittens) I wanted to make some PJ pants.
Mission accomplished! I finally got to try out the Perky Pom Pom Hat tutorial by Prudent Baby. I couldn't get over how easy it was! It took me about 45 minutes and that was with my 5 year old's assistance.
Got a hat and some pants completed. I only have a picture of the hat right now, but will post more photos as I can!